1st read
Wednesday, 01 June 2022

Memories of the Neutral Bay Music Hall

Written by Barry Creyton
On 29 March 2022, the S,B&W Foundation, as part of their local North Sydney Council’s Senior’s Week Program, held a special event celebrating the greatly-loved but sadly-demolished old Music Hall, Neutral Bay. An afternoon of  songs, memorabilia and stories recalled memories of the popular Victorian-style theatre restaurant founded by George and Lorna Miller in the 1960s. Actors such as Barry Creyton and Noeline Brown got their start there, and the following anecdote contributed by BARRY CREYTON was one of many shared at the event.

Christine Little 8 Nov 2021George and Lorna Miller, the host and hostess of the Music Hall Theatre Restaurant, Neutral Bay. Courtesy Christine Little.In 1961 when I first moved to Sydney as an aspiring actor, I knew many at the Independent Theatre including my long time friend Maggie Dence.

I set my sights on the newly refurbished Music Hall Theatre at Neutral Bay. I determined I would play the villain in East Lynne, a part my grandfather had played late in the 19th century. I was twenty years too young for the part, but I virtually badgered my way into it, and there began a series of villains, some written unashamedly by me, for me! These established me in Sydney theatre and led directly to my being cast in the Mavis Bramston Show.

I remember the opening night of East Lynne vividly. The paint was barely dry on the set, but the evening was an enormous success and established the theatre for many years to come. Here is where the Independent Theatre and the Music Hall Theatre merged for one exchange which has lived long in my memory.

The redoubtable Doris Fitton, the anchor of the Independent, was resplendent at our opening. As well as her renowned credentials at the Independent, she was also well known for sleeping through entire theatrical productions, including some of her own. But this I didn't know when I was introduced to her after the performance, so I was startled when she asked ‘Which one were you, the hero or the villain?’

I replied modestly, ‘I was the villain.’

‘Oh yes,’ she said, ‘you were very good.’

I was relieved I hadn't played the hero, but less so when I discovered she’d dozed through much of the evening.

Those were heady days in Sydney theatre. The Ensemble, the Music Hall and the Independent were brave standouts when most of the mainstream theatres were filled with the lavish J.C. Williamson productions.

Sydney theatre has changed over the years, some for better, some (like the demolition of so many beautiful theatres) for worse. But the spirit established by the Independent and the Music Hall still exists, I’m sure. You might keep it alive by singing a few bars of the number I did in East Lynne: As the evil villain, I had only one redeeming moment—1 sang ‘I Don’t Want to Play in Your Yard’, complete with soft shoe.


Thanks to Susan Mills, archivist at the S,B&W Foundation for her assistance in preparing this article, and to Barry Creyton for allowing us to republish his piece.

For more information about the Seaborn, Broughton & Walford Foundation, please visit:

Read 310 times Last modified on Wednesday, 29 June 2022