Harry M Miller

It was joan bruceor Anne Haddy who informed me Harry M. Miller had advertised for a trainee, and they thought I should apply. The advertisement was specific: males under 23. There were several hundred applicants, all of whom were put through a rigorous interview process: first with Freddie Gibson, then with Harry M. By some miracle, I was successful. I was employed as a production assistant/general factotum/dog’s body. The company was at its creative zenith and Harry M. was leading the way, showing other producers how it ought to be done.

The three-years—1969, ’70, and ’71, which I passed working for Harry M. Miller Attractions, were the most pivotal in the company’s development. It was an exhilarating chapter in my life, and ground-breaking for the Australian theatre, and its practitioners.

HMM was the most charismatic of men. I recall hanging-off his every word—even when he was ranting. I was fascinated his nails were manicured and coated with clear varnish. He was, always, impeccably turned-out. His suits came from Peter Jackson in lieu of program contra; imported fashions from John Lane in Double Bay. Mr. Lane was what might be described as, ‘a terribly grand old queen’. Richard Hunt, George Street, was the gentlemen’s outfitter of distinction. His shoes were Italian slip-on. Ties were silk. Shirts with French cuffs were made to order. He was one of the first to wear a pink shirt, and always had a contrasting handkerchief in the breast pocket of his jacket, or the obligatory double-breasted, navy-blue, double-vented, brass-buttoned blazer. He wore a signet ring on his right pinkie finger. I wanted, but never dared, to tell him, traditionally, the crest should be worn faced inward to protect the design from being stolen. The ring was engraved with a phoenix rising from the ashes. The same symbol was embossed on his letterhead. The print on his cards was raised.

During the 1970s, HMM lived a social life. He was enjoying the fruits of his success. He was involved with those arts organisations which he believed brought him the kudos he craved, and relished. He was not unhappy with the shape and form of his public image. He lent his considerable talent and energy as Commercial and Promotion consultant to the Australian Opera; Member of the NSW Art Gallery Foundation Appeal Committee; member of the federal council of the Metropolitan Opera Auditions; and councillor of the Friends of the Australia Opera. His advice and approval were sought, keenly. His opinions were given and quoted with alacrity.

While he did not invest his own money in any of his shows, his hefty management fees for HAIR (it returned 275% on investment), Jesus Christ Superstar,The Secretary Bird,The Boys in the Band, and commissions from his management stable of clients, provided a more-than-steady cash flow. When asked the difference between an agent and a manager, he replied: ‘15%.’ (An agent charged 10%; HMM took 25%.) Mr. Miller acquired a taste for the finer things in life. His horses were agisted in Centennial Park, Sydney. He rode regularly, and played polo. He went through a Vespa scooter stage—whizzing around the streets of Sydney without a helmet. The garage housed a Rolls. He employed a driver/houseman, and God help you if happened to upset Kitty, his long-suffering, discreet housekeeper who managed his life in Rosemont Avenue, Woollahra! There was no shortage of affaires de coeur, and cast members were not, by definition, necessarily off-limits.

HMM

His self-edit button was not always as honed as it might have been.  HMM was witty—sometimes embarrassingly gauche, and fast-talking. He laughed at his own jokes. He manipulated journalists to his advantage—effortlessly, and like no-one since. He favoured Brian Hoad from The Bulletin magazine, and Sheila Scotter, editor of Vogue. Privately, he mocked those who pursued him, wanting to write ‘the in-depth story about the real Harry M.’. They followed him around for days, only to regurgitate the same story—the one he expertly dictated. He was a past-master at guarding his image—same character, different hat! His persona was a figment of his own imagination. What they failed to realise, all of them, was he played them like a salmon. He told them what they wanted to hear, and divulged only what he wanted them to print. He had a capacity to make people feel special in his life, and he led interviewers to believe he was sharing a special confidence. Neither were true. He was a smart, opportunistic soldier-of-fortune, who was not oblivious to his personal charm; a brilliant entrepreneur who tapped the public psyche. He listened and ‘borrowed’ good ideas—never to source them.

His personal peccadilloes notwithstanding, my profound awe for him never abated. To the end-of-his-life I addressed him as Mr. Miller. He never invited me to call him Harry, which I suspect was deliberate and his form of relationship control. For six-months I worked from a desk in the corner of his office; consequently, I was privy to the detail of all his conversations—personal and private. Never once did ask me to leave the room. Still, I know things about him which have never been made public, not even by HMM in his biography. I suspect most of those who may have known are dead; the remaining few are silent. I saw every document which crossed his desk. He was exacting, and on occasions I was subjected to the sharp-edge of his tongue. Instinct tells me it had something to do with my manner-of-speech. Several times, in a fit of excessive pique, he accused me of being ‘la-de-dah’. What he construed as indifference to his tirade only served to exacerbate his anger. I was 22, and innocent; he was 35, and sophisticated. I do not believe he ever considered the power imbalance in the relationship. In truth, I was shattered to my core by his sometimes ugly, abusive behaviour.

Jennifer West

Freddie Gibson

At the end of three-years I was fired, summarily. I disobeyed his unambiguous command. I arranged for Jennifer West, a friend and colleague based in Perth, to be brought to Sydney—at the company’s expense, to audition for The Secretary Bird. Back in Perth, she did a newspaper interview and was uncomplimentary about the project. She was quoted: ‘I’m not sure it’s the sort of play I want to do.’ Unbeknownst to her, that was not a remote possibility. HMM was unimpressed: ‘She’s beautiful, but she’s a bloody amazon! She’s taller than Patrick!’ On reading the press cutting he was livid, and held me responsible. I was ordered not contact her. I did, and despite my strident, unequivocal directive to the contrary, Jennifer wrote to HMM. Caught-out, she ham-fistedly attempted to justify the foolishness. She pleaded it was another of those ‘misquotes’ for which the press is so famous! He was in a rage—with her, and me. Contemptuously, he threw her letter into his wastepaper basket. I knew from his reaction, Jennifer West had cooked my goose! It was only a matter of time.

Freddie Gibson, unmistakably inebriated, telephoned late in the evening. He delivered me the most abusive, accusatory, expletive-laden tirade which ended my tenure with HMM. I was told not to return to the office, under any circumstances. I never saw, or spoke with, Freddie Gibson again. When I learned he was dying, I telephoned his home. His wife, Jan, explained he was incapable of talking with me, but he did smile when she mentioned my name. Whenever I think of Freddie Gibson, and these days it is quite often, I remember him only as he was in the office; kind and amusing, and wearing a silk bow-tie. He was very supportive. I have forgotten about the abusive phone call. That was another life, in another land! Besides, they are all dead …

*Frederick John (Freddie) Gibson 1934–2013.

Possibly out of guilt, HMM helped orchestrate for me to join the Melbourne Theatre Company under the artistic direction of John Sumner. The whole disagreeable saga proved a blessing in disguise. HMM was never told, but Margaret Enchelmaier (his private secretary) used the company account to pay for my return airfare to Melbourne for the interview with John Sumner. She disagreed with HMM’s decision, and his treatment of me. Margaret assured me the Melbourne Theatre Company was the best thing I could do for my career: ‘It’s time for you to go but remember what he’s taught you, and use it.’ I did, and I did. It stood me in good stead. I was so well trained, when I was living in London, Margaret Sumner, the scientist wife of John, told me on one of my visits to stay with them in Stonesfield, outside of Oxford: ‘You should know, John thinks, of all his stage managers over the years, you were the best.’ I am not sure I took it seriously, but it did cause me to reflect on Mr. Miller’s utter training of me.

Ironically, our association did not end. Whenever HMM needed something done in Melbourne he telephoned. It was as if he considered me an eternal employee. My dismissal was never mentioned, ever. Curiously, his actions ran contrary to what he had espoused. He talked of me and a succession plan. I recall him telling the journalist. Brian Hoad: ‘I have found someone to take over the business, and I’m in the process of training him.’ I was the only one whom he subjected to the thorough training.

Margaret Enchelmaier & Graham Allan

Patti Mostyn

For those working with, and for, HMM, and we were a small team, he demanded perfection. While he never hesitated to express dissatisfaction, often it was couched in terms which left you with a feeling of personal failure; equally, for all his public bonhomie, he was a man of sometimes immoderate temperament. He was given to shouting; to displays of bad-temper, and ranting. Often times, Freddie Gibson or Margaret Enchelmaier had to act as a pacifier. To be emphatic, it was part of his entrepreneurial genius, but he could be as savage as he was kind and generous.

Led by HMM, the team at 647 George Street, Haymarket, Sydney, comprised Frederick (Freddie ) J. Gibson—joint Managing Director and  principal executive director; Margaret Enchelmaier—HMM’s private secretary; Christine Dobinson—Freddie’s secretary: Babette Smith—production assistant;  secretary Jenny Wise; Sandra Patterson—publicist, later Judith Rich, then Patti Mostyn and Jackie Drews; John Finlay—advertising manager; Neil Bartley and Simon Dickie—trainee advertising/publicity assistants; company treasurer Margaret Nestor—a most churlish, unprepossessing woman with obviously died red hair, who took an instant dislike and made my working days in the accounts department a total misery. She did, on several occasions, reduce me to tears. She was so stridently vicious, had it not been for the comforting support of party-booking organiser Mrs. Bettie Hallett I would have resigned; comptroller Richard Harper, subsequently, Edward Wagemans and assistant Lionel Leo; HAIR company manager Peter Mackennal. Mrs. Hallett and her off-sider, Marie Bartley, were crammed into a space the size of a cupboard at the back of the building! They spent their days working the telephones, contacting workplace social clubs organising group bookings. Of that Sydney pack, and excluding external creatives, I’m guessing only Jackie Drews, Jenny Wise, Simon Dickie and Patti Mostyn survive to recall the halcyon days of that first decade of the organisation, when the force and magnetism of the Harry M. Miller juggernaut single-handedly changed the face of Australian Theatre.

647 George Street, Haymarket

Camille Spector & Simon Dickie

The building and offices at 647 George Street were not grand. The 2nd floor reception and executive area were smart; however, passing through the door to the back, things were less impressive—two large offices, and a lot of second-hand desks and glass-and-timber partitions from the previous occupant. The 3rd floor accounts department was equally utilitarian. The working areas were surprisingly silent, and very industrious. There was not a lot of chatter. HMM told all his clients: ‘I won’t give you 100% of my time, but I will give you 100% of my effort.’ He expected the same of his employees. Lunch was eaten at your desk, and for the most-part, in silence. He insisted your desk must be cleared, and all phone calls returned, before you left at the end-of-the-day. It was not beyond him to check after you had left the building. Woe betide if he found one of those ubiquitous, yellow telephone message slips!

The kitchen fridge was packed with the most delicious continental goodies from the famous Haymarket delicatessen, owned and operated by an Austrian or Swiss German. The treats were for HMM, only. You touched anything on pain-of-death. Occasionally, I took the risk. Nothing was said.

Sue Becker

Metro Theatre, Sydney

HMM managed Graham Kennedy; ABC television fitness guru, Sue Becker; television director, Ron Way; actors Carmen Duncan and Stuart Wagstaff; television chef, Graeme Kerr; and for a time, television host, Tony Barber.

Curiously, the arrangement with both Kennedy and Becker ended acrimoniously, and involved money. Becker sued him, retrospectively, for a refund of commission. It ended-up in court and was settled in her favour. Sue Becker was a difficult client, and was the reason HMM handed her to me. He did not have the time to massage, endlessly, her over-inflated ego. She had an enormous fan base. Every week she made two—or three-personal appearances—intra—and interstate, for a sizeable fee. She was extremely vexing, and complained constantly about the calibre of the people and standard of the event. She attended Roedean which is widely regarded as the Eton College of all-girls boarding schools in the United Kingdom. She demanded constant attention and believed her own publicity. She argued her ten-minute ABC television show—Swing in Time with Sue Becker—should be a half-hour program. The ABC management was approached, and they rejected the idea—unambiguously. Eventually, they cancelled her show—partly as a consequence of her imperiousness. She moved to Tasmania and there was no further contact.

*Sue Becker died 2007 aged 79.

Graham Kennedy

In 1970-71, Graham Kennedy did a Bowater Scott paper towel television commercial for $100,000. His two-year fee was touted as the highest, ever, for a 30-second television spot. In 1989 Graham sacked Harry M. when it was discovered he was being paid a secret commission. HMM sued Kennedy for a 20-percent commission on earnings for the preceding year. The matter went to court. He lost and was ordered to pay Kennedy $75,699. Paradoxically, it seemed the court did not understand the role of the agent/manager. Graham Kennedy was demanding. It needed Margaret Enchelmaier, HMM, and me to keep him totally satisfied.

Graham always travelled by train between Sydney and Melbourne. Our first meeting was at Central Station. I was clutching a publicity photograph to recognise him. He stayed in HMM’s mansion flat in Woollahra. I was at his disposal for lunches at all the right restaurants, and dinners at Rosemont Avenue cooked by Kitty, the housekeeper.  It was exhausting. At the famed Beppi’s, Graham encountered the actor Ronnie Frazer lunching with three other middle-aged, confirmed bachelors. I was 23. I was not introduced, and I spoke not a word to them. From the ogling and exchange of banter, it was obvious what they concluded of me and my relationship with Graham Kennedy! Paradoxically, nothing could have been more innocent.

Sadly, in the end HMM and Graham were irrevocably estranged. I would posit HMM was responsible for Graham’s national success.

*Graham Kennedy died 2005 aged 71.

Stuart Wagstaff

Tony Barber

Stuart Wagstaff was the least troublesome. He was the Benson & Hedgesman for which he was extremely well paid. The television campaign was so successful, the company continued paying long after the contract had ended. Stuart appeared in 116 commercials over 20-years. They believed he was so inextricably associated with their product he deserved the financial consideration.

HMM was fond of Stuart, who conceded he was a jobbing actor who got lucky in Australia. He was grateful for what HMM created for him. It was a fulsome and satisfying career, and well deserved.

*Stuart Wagstaff died March 2015 aged 90.

Gloria Dawn photographed by Harry Jay

Joachim Tenschert

Tony Barber was a former advertising executive. He cast himself as the whistler in the Cambridge cigarette commercial. The whistling was done by the actress, Gloria Dawn, with whom I did the Berliner Ensemble production of Mother Courage for the Melbourne Theatre Company, playing at the Princess Theatre. In hindsight the production should have toured. The director, Joachim Tenschert, had worked on the original production with Bertolt Brecht and his wife, actress Helene Weigel. Gloria was dazzling in the role. According to Joachim, she was the best—ever—after Helene Weigel.

The music was composed by Paul Dessau. The MTC production was an exact replica of the 1949 production, which led to the establishment of the Berliner Ensemble Theatre Company in East Berlin. The rigidity of the production was alien. Wendy Hughes, who played the mute daughter, Kattrin, found the role difficult, and the direction exasperating. When told to take five steps, and not six, Wendy reacted. It was not her finest moment. I recall dragging her aside and engaging in a very vigorous conversation about her behaviour towards Joachim. Feisty at the best of times, and we were great friends, I silenced her into submission. She acquiesced. We never mentioned it again.

Gloria Dawn approached me in her quiet, understated way and said, pointing to the word ‘shit’ in the script: ‘I’m sorry, love, but I don’t work blue. I don’t want to be any trouble for you, I’m happy if you want to get someone else to play the part.’ I reassured her and spoke with John Sumner, who said: ‘Rock, tell her to cut-it. It doesn’t matter.’ I did, and she was happy. Every night, when Frederick Parslow, as the cook, used the word ‘fuck’, she turned upstage, with her back to the audience. Gloria was a woman of faith.

Gloria Dawn & Wendy Hughes in Mother Courage

Working with Gloria Dawn was a rare treat. One night she exited the stage into the prompt corner, having done a huge emotional scene, and said to me: ‘Could you tell Mr. Ziegfeld, I can’t keep coming here every night to do this audition. He has to make-up his mind. If he wants a brunette, I’m not his girl!’ We both laughed like drains and she went-off to her dressing room. One never would have guessed her terminal cancer was lurking. What a loss …

Long before it came into vogue, HMM was a proponent of natural, carbonated mineral water. He discovered Hepburn Springs and launched the water onto the market. Weeks were spent preparing the artwork and settling on a very stylish label and logo. The Bulletin magazine was shanghaied into supporting him, and Brian Hoad had first bite of the cherry.

I was told to set-up a photoshoot with HMM and the stall holders from the Haymarket fruit and vegetable market. (It was soon before the venue closed down and became Paddy’s market.) They were delighted to be involved, and they each went home with a box of mineral water. 

The official launch was a luncheon in a seedy restaurant in Kensington, or Zetland, and was a strictly male event. A large circular Perspex pool—about 6-feet deep, and filled with mineral water, was set-up in the centre of room, surrounded by tables of leering journos. We did not mention it was not mineral water—that was impossible. It was tap-water treated with carbon dioxide (CO₂). No-one mentioned carbon dioxide bubbling through water reduces the temperature.

HMM advertising Hepburn Springs Mineral Water

Peter Mackennal

A stripper had been hired—she was paid $250, to swim naked in the pool. The water was so cold, the hapless girl was turning blue and could only swim around for a couple of minutes. She was required to repeat the routine a number of times, while the inebriated men tried desperately to catch a glimpse of you-know-what as she frog-kicked in the icy water. HMM took to the microphone and was at his most vulgar. The journalists were captivated! The whole tawdry event was deemed a roaring success, and Hepburn Springs mineral water was well-and-truly launched.

HMM was an early riser, and weekly 8 a.m. production meetings in his office were compulsory—even for the creatives working on various productions. He berated those who were late, and no excuse was acceptable. It was reckless to argue, and his anger mounted if you did not have an acceptable answer to his many questions. HAIR stage director, Sandra McKenzie, who was mostly at the Metro Theatre for eight performances a week, complained bitterly to him about meeting at such an ungodly hour. He valued her, and she was never chastised. 

One end of HMM’s spacious office was a sitting area comprising four large sofas surrounding a large Perspex coffee table. For reasons unknown, HMM had a metre-long, metal ruler. On this particular morning, he and HAIR company manager, Peter Mackennal, clashed over a management protocol for the show. It was obvious neither was prepared to capitulate. Instead of agreeing and ignoring—which was what we did for the most part, Peter persisted, belligerently. The outburst happened in an instant. HMM seized the metal ruler, raised it above his head, and with his full force, smashed it into the top of the table, shouting: ‘You’re fucking-well fired.’ It was a challenging moment. Peter was reduced to tears. We were told to: ‘Get out, all of you!’ HMM did not rescind and Peter’s tenure was terminated, immediately. He was gone within the hour. He and I had been friends, and to my profound regret I never saw him again. Peter’s life was not without complication.

*Peter Mackennal died in Noosa, 2019, aged 77, having enjoyed a successful career as an artist.

To be continued

Note on images

All images courtesy of the author with the exception of the program covers which come from the THA archive.

HMM and Johnny Ray

Chequersnightclub, owned and operated by importers and restaurateurs Keith and Dennis Wong, was located at 79 Goulburn Street, Sydney (1959). They presented a cavalcade of international cabaret artists. It attracted a colourful and often notorious clientele of the good, the bad, and the ugly! With a staff of 120, and seating 550-patrons, Morris Lansburgh, the Miami and Las Vegas hotel-millionaire, said Chequers was “better than either the Copacabana or the Latin Quarter in New York”. The Wongs paid weekly fees of £7500 to Sarah Vaughan; £6000 to Tony Martin and Shelley Berman; and £5000 to Frances Faye.

Garry Van Egmond

Louis Armstong and HMM

HMM was introduced to Dennis and Keith Wong (1963) by Sol Shapiro, an internationally influential agent with the prestigious Wiliam Morris Agency, New York, and with whom HMM had negotiated earlier concert contracts. Subsequently, in 1963 the Wong brothers and HMM formed Pan-Pacific Promotions. They were a formidable triumvirate. Garry Van Egmond was their Melbourne representative. He worked from an office in the now-demolished Southern Cross Hotel, Bourke and Exhibition Streets. It was ‘THE’ hotel of the day. It was where The Beatles stayed. When the concierge denied actress Joan Brokenshire entry, she removed the offending trousers and was allowed to proceed wearing an obscenely mini coat-dress—showing her superb legs to great advantage!

HMM with Judy Garland and Patti Amphlett

HMM and Shirley Bassey

Pan Pacific brought Sarah Vaughan (a financial disaster, and most patrons paid to see the support act—DON LANE), Johnny Ray, Dizzy Gillespie, Ella Fitzgerald, Chubby Checker, Shirley Bassey, Tom Jones, Leslie Uggams, The Rolling Stones, Sammy Davis Jr., Eartha Kitt, Judy Garland, Artur Rubenstein, Louis Armstrong & Trini Lopez, The Merseybeat Sound, Starlift '64, Surfside, The Folk Festival, Leslie Uggams, Frances Faye, Tom Jones and Hermans Hermits to Australia.

Miller's partnership with the Wong brothers continued until early 1967 when he bought-out their share of Pan-Pacific Promotions and established Harry M. Miller Attractions Pty. Ltd., principally, as a consequence of the financially disastrous, Fortnight of Furore,tour by, The Who, The Small Faces,and Paul Jones, January 1968; and The Monkees—September-October 1968;  Subsequently, HMM abandoned concert promotion and concentrated on theatrical production in Australia.

 

The Noël Coward Festival—Present Laughter and Private Livesat the Palace Theatre, Sydney (1968) starring British actress Rosemary Martin (Noël Coward’s choice), and Stuart Wagstaff, marked one of his first forays. Sue Becker—known for her television physical jerks programme on ABC television, played Monica in Present Laughter.

HMM promoted only two other rock tours—the controversial Joe Cocker in 1972, and David Cassidy, 1974.

Television director, Ron Way, was an HMM client, and one for whom I was logistically responsible. Ron directed the acclaimed television specials featuring Shirley Bassey—her dress caused people to ask if she was wearing knickers; Louis Armstrong; Sammy Davis Jr., and Matt Monro, who convinced himself my name is Mervyn!

Ron Way

Shirley Bassey in that dress

Ron directed 45-episodes of My Name’s McGooley,What’s Yours?; 22-episodes of Good Morning, Mr Doubleday;Rooted;10-episodes of Seven Little Australians;Shannon’s Mob;the film Frenchman’s Farm;The Mavis Bramston Show;Boney;Spyforce;Woobinda; 182-episodes of This Is Your Life; and countless television commercials, most notably, Graham Kennedy in the famous Bowater Scott paper towel commercial produced by Ross Wood Productions Sydney, and for which Graham was paid an incredible amount of money—and for two-years!

The BP Super Show was a loosely scheduled series of musical specials 1959–70. Ron directed the last of the shows, Hans Christian Andersen—scripted musical film which starred the British actors Patrick Wymark, and John Fraser, in the title role—both of whom were appearing in HMM’s production of Sleuth at the Theatre Royal, Castlereagh Street. The Dick Van Dyke Show, comedy duo, Morey Amsterdam (his 5th visit), and Richard Deacon, were touring Australia and joined a cast including Patti Newton, Bryan Davies, Rosie Strugess, and Stuart Wagstaff—another HMM client. A Nine Network production, it was produced by Stefan Haag, under the musical direction of Geoff Harvey. It was Patrick Wymark’s last television performance. The film of Hans Christian Andersen went to air five-weeks after Patrick’s death at his hotel in Melbourne. He was due to open in Sleuth at the Comedy Theatre.

*Ron Way, 1933–29 June 2019. He was 85.

Hutchinson Scott’s set for The Secretary Bird

In 1969, Patrick Macnee, who played John Steed in the television series, The Avengers, came to Australia to star in a Sydney season of William Douglas Home’s drawing-room comedy, The Secretary Bird; directed by Philip Dudley, with a glorious set designed by the acclaimed Hutchinson Scott. It was an event—a financial bonanza!

There were queues at the stage door wanting Patrick’s autograph. His name made the work of the party-booking ladies so much easier. They were coming to see John Steed—he could have been reading the telephone book. It changed audience’s perception of the theatre. While many English and American film and theatre box-office names had, over the years, accepted invitations to lead productions in Australia—and with great success—Patrick was the first of such television star-names to appear. His television persona resonated with audiences. The Secretary Bird was the first time producers witnessed the seismic power of ‘the box’, and its overwhelming potential to attract a whole new audience. It proved a watershed in Australian theatre. It broke-down the barrier of perceived elitism. For the two-decades following, and as a direct consequence of Patrick’s phenomenal success, producers brought a cavalcade of television stars—some good, some not so good, to the perform in Australia productions. While it did create some understandable consternation in the rank-and-file of local actors, there was no doubting the import’s capacity to draw an audience—that section of the public who did not, as a rule-of-thumb, attend the theatre. Conversely, Nancye Hayes, and not the American import Anne Hilton, should have played the lead in the J.C. Williamson production of Promises, Promises.Equally, the male American import, Orson Bean, was not a box-office name, and he sang quite nicely!

*Orson Bean 1928-2020, aged 91.

Nancye Hayes

Promises, Promises program

In the Sydney Mirror newspaper, critic Frank Harris wrote: “As for the Australians, Nancye Hayes stole the spotlight effortlessly with her gorgeously comic performance as the pick-up girl, outwardly bland and disarming, but as cunning as a wagon-load of vixens with her lead-on talk to the bedroom.”

No expense was spared on Patrick’s costumes which came from John Lane, Double Bay. They cost many hundreds of dollars. At the end of the Sydney season Patrick commandeered the lot—including the silk scarves, Turnbull and Asser shirts, wool and suede cardigan, and knee-length, black, silk socks. The selection of shoes were from Bally—loafers/slip-ons in premium brown suede; black velvet, embroidered loafers; and black, patent leather evening shoes with a grosgrain bow.  

Patrick Macnee

Mary Miller

Patrick’s English co-star, Mary Miller, arrived with an impeccable pedigree. She was a founding member of the London’s National Theatre. She played Melinda to Laurence Olivier’s Captain Brazen in the restoration comedy, The Recruiting Officer, by George Farquhar. Other cast members in the legendary production included Maggie Smith, Robert Stephens, Michael Gambon, Derek Jacobi, Lynn Redgrave, Colin Blakely and Sarah Miles; directed by the celebrated William Gaskill; Mary played Emilia in Laurence Olivier’s Othello, directed by John Dexter, with Frank Finlay as Iago, and Maggie Smith as Desdemona.

Mary was the better actor. Patrick complained constantly about her performance. He said, unkindly, she played the part as if it were Chekov. Like many women’s roles in such drawing-room comedies the wife was a mostly thankless part. Her character was a theatrical device to create the plot—in this instance for the husband to outwit the wife’s proposed divorce and her intended new and younger husband.

The casting of Mary is a puzzlement. She was unknown to Australia audiences, and the role could have been played by a number of actresses. British-born, Carol Raye, would have been perfect. Mary bought her costumes with her from London, including the ugliest pair of butter-cup-yellow patent leather, stumpy-heeled shoes which served only to draw attention to her thick ankles. HMM saw them for the first time at a dress rehearsal and they never made onto the stage again! Their fate remains a mystery. At HMM’s insistence, a pair of dark-brown crepe, ill-fitting, bell-bottom, slacks were replaced. He hated the colour!

Fredric Abbott was an Australian actor based in London. He, too, was brought home for The Secretary Bird. He was an agreeable man, if slightly dull, and his casting was equally unexpected. Fred was not conventionally good-looking, and he attracted minimal media interest. Actor Frederick Parslow might have been a better choice.

Other cast members were Jan Kingsbury and Betty Dyson.

Bill Dowd (later a designer), Terence O’Connell (later a director), and Sonia Humphrey (a former Australian Ballet company member who suffered a career-ending injury, and later an ABC presenter/newsreader), were stage management and props. Each performance they were required to cook-up a full English breakfast—including scrambled eggs—to be consumed onstage.

Frederick Parslow

Fredric Abbott

*Philip Dudley died 1981 aged 45. In a short but illustrious career, he directed Margaret Leighton and Noël Coward in a television version (1969) of Coward’s play, The Vortex; Nigel Havers in the acclaimed television series (1978) of R.F. Delderfield’s novel, A Horseman Riding By;The Corn is Green starring Dame Wendy Hiller;numerous episodes of Z Cars, Softly, Softly: Task Force,with Stratford Johns, and Tales of the Unexpected,starring, Frank Finlay, Siobhán McKenna, and Amanda Redman.

*Patrick Macnee died 2015, aged 93.

*Janet Kingsbury died 2024, aged 85. She and director, Philip Dudley, enjoyed a closeness during his time in Australia.

*Mary Miller died 2020, Denville Hall, London, aged 90. Mary was, for a time, married to the Scottish actor Bill Simpson who played the title role in the long-running television series, Dr. Finlay’s Casebook.

*Frederic Abbott died July 1996, aged 67.

*Frederick Parslow died 2017, aged 84.

*James Fishburn—stage director, died 1989, aged 57.

*Sonia Humprhey died 2011, aged 63.

Patrick, Mary Miller and Philip Dudley on their way to rehearsal

The Secretary Bird was the final production at the Palace Theatre, Castlereagh Street, before its demolition, 1970. Built in 1896, it was a glorious Victorian theatre, although the underground dressing-rooms were a labyrinth. Also, the theatre shared a common wall with the adjoining hotel’s kitchen. As a result, you could smell, throughout the whole theatre, whatever it was they were cooking for dinner!

The Avengers, 1961–69, with his co-stars Honor Blackman, then Diana Rigg, and latterly, Linda Thorson, was internationally successful. It changed the course of Patrick’s life. He went from a successful, jobbing-actor to a leading man. Paradoxically, Patrick’s fame came by default. The original leading man, Ian Hendry, filmed one season of The Avengers then elected to leave to make films. Patrick, who played his side-kick, was handed the role on a platter! Ian Hendry was in the mould of James Bond. Patrick was dapper and podgy. He wore an elasticised girdle!

*Ian Hendry 1931-1984: aged 53.

William Douglas Home watching a rehearsal in Australia

Patrick was a capable, reliable actor who delivered a perfectly acceptable performance. There was a predictable speech cadence to his every character, regardless. While the reviews were not fantastic, The Telegraph newspaper was particularly caustic. It read: “four-hours on a pendulum is a long time!” HMM was incandescent with rage and complained to the editor—berating the critic. In full-flight he was something to behold! He threatened to sue, arguing the review would affect the box-office. People would be scared-off because of the inaccurate running-time.  Consequently, they apologised, and accorded the production much positive publicity. The Secretary Bird did sell-out business. HMM was unaware, and I confess for the first time, I, together with several other of his employees, left at the interval. I thought it dull! I was required to be in the theatre for 5– of the eight-weekly performances, and to report back to Freddie Gibson. 

The Secretary Bird schedule was demanding: Monday-Thursday 8.15pm. Friday and Saturday 5.30pm and 8.30pm. There was no Wednesday matinee.

Patrick, who was between his second and third wives, was a most agreeable man. He was tall—6’1”, with a florid complexion, and a full-head of dark, thick, curly hair. He was given to anxiety, and carried a string of Greek worry beads with which he fiddled, constantly. While he appeared socially confident he was, for the most part, a nervous Ned! Patrick was an overweight vegetarian—by 14-pounds, he claimed,

He came from good-stock and identified as a Scot. His parents separated after his mother announced she was a lesbian and moved-in with her partner, Evelyn Spottiswoode, whose fortune came from Dewar’s whisky business.  Patrick dubbed her “Uncle Evelyn”. She helped pay for his schooling at Summer Fields School (Harold Macmillan was a pupil), and Eton, in the shadow of Windsor Castle, and from where he was expelled for selling pornography and acting as a bookmaker. Without notice, his father took-off and went to live in India!

Ironically, Patrick enjoyed being feted by the great-and-the-good! He was treated like a movie star and he relished being a big fish in a small pond. There were several dalliances, including a production assistant who thought he might help to advance her career. The fan mail was phenomenal. I answered every letter, and they were signed by Patrick. He was ensconced in the renowned Sebel Town House for 16-weeks. Also, Mary Miller was there for the rehearsal period. After a very late opening Friday night, and a matinee on the Saturday, she stayed one extra night before moving to a house in Paddington. HMM docked her salary for the cost of the additional night’s accommodation. According to Mary, soon after she arrived from London HMM invited her to dinner. To her surprise she found it necessary to specify in the clearest-of-terms the inviolable parameters of their professional association. The type of welcome she was being offered was most unexpected and of the kind she did not want! Perhaps it goes some way to explaining HMM’s accommodation stinginess—which was most unusual on his part.

Patrick with Mary Miller

Googie Withers and Alfred Sandor in Plaza Suite

In 1969, Australian audiences were in awe of imported stars. At the same time as The Secretary Bird, Googie Withers and Alfred Sandor were two-blocks down Castlereagh Street at the Theatre Royal doing Neil Simon’s, Plaza Suite.

*Googie Withers—Karachi, 1917, died Sydney 2011. Aged 94.

*Alfred Sandor—Budapest, 1918, died Sydney 1983. Aged 64.

The 1970 Melbourne season opened at the Princess Theatre. Patrick was having none of Mary Miller and Anne Charleston took-over the role; Noel Trevarthen replaced Fredric Abbott; and Barbara Stephens was the secretary bird, replacing Janet Kingsbury, whom Patrick considered “too old” for the role. Esme Melville played the housekeeper. James Fishburn directed, and Norma Tullo did the décor and costumes. Anne Charleston was a single mother and touring with her infant son, Nicholas Ravenswood. Patrick was horrified when he saw the standard of her Brisbane accommodation. He complained, bitterly, to HMM: “It’s like Tobacco Road!” he bellowed. “She can’t stay there!” Anne, and infant Nicholas, were moved, immediately, into same hotel accommodation as Patrick, and at no cost to her! 

HMM horseriding

In the April of 1970, HMM’s horse threw him and he broke his leg. It proved a trying-time for everyone; however, it did not stop him from working, and only served to exacerbate his  irascibility. He went, on crutches, to Canberra for the opening night of The Secretary Bird. He borrowed from me a magnificent walking stick which had been gifted by a friend. He never did return it, and I was too embarrassed to remind him.

Predictably, The Bulletin magazine critic, Rex Cramphorn, wrote contemptuously: “Husband (to errant wife), ‘My poor old darling, you have got it bad’. WIFE: ‘You make it sound like measles’! The quotation alone is a complete review.” The production of The Secretary Birdplayed to capacity houses across the country—and in New Zealand, something none of Mr. Cramphorn’s productions managed to achieve—ever! While the play was not Shakespeare, it was what the audience wanted, and it was not without social merit.

William Douglas Home wrote some 50 plays, most of them comedies in an upper-class setting, including The Reluctant Debutante;The Kingfisher (which I did with Googie Withers, John McCallum, and Frank Thring, directed by George Ogilvie—John Frost was the stage manager), Lloyd George Knew My Father—Sir Ralph Richardson and his wife Merriel Forbes played it in Australia;The Chiltern Hundreds;and,Now Barabbas—the film version of which was written by Douglas Home and Anatole de Grunwald, and starred Richard Greene, Sir Cedric Hardwicke, Kathleen Harrison, Kenneth More, and Richard Burton.

The Secretary Bird played for a total of 10-months:

Palace Theatre, Sydney 18 September–10 December 1969

Princess Theatre, Melbourne— 31 March 1970

Hunter Theatre, Newcastle— April 1970

Canberra Theatre, Canberra—14-21 May 1970

SGIO Theatre Brisbane—June 1970

Comedy Theatre Melbourne—July 1970 (return season)

New Zealand (1970) Auckland, Wellington, Palmerston North, Christchurch, Invercargill.

Ken Delo and Jonathan Daly

Anthony Marriott

No Sex Please, We’re British ran in London’s West End from June 1971 until September 1987, for a total of 6,761 performances, and in three different theatres. It was directed for 16-years by Australian, Allan Davis. Written by Alistair Foot, who died a few weeks before opening night in London, and Anthony Marriott, who readily acknowledged the serendipity of his good fortune, saying about the play: “Let’s face it, the thing’s a freak! I thought it would run for about six-weeks.”

HMM contracted Jonathan Daley to star as Brian Runnicles. His previous television fame in Australia—the comedy duo of Delo and Daley—suggested a likely success. No Sex Please,is a perfect British farce—a barrage of double entendre, mistaken identities, physical high-jinks—real people in unreal situations! The show opened to predictable reviews—not that it mattered. The audience adored it. They shrieked with laughter. Jonathan Daly was a triumph. The director, Tony Marriott, provided exactly what the public expected—and wanted! 

The Australian cast were Malcolm Steed, Marion Heathfield, Alan Kingsford-Smith, Ken Fraser, Tony Hawkins, Frank Garfield, Norman Kaye, Robyn Moase, and Liddy Clark. HMM asked for me to be out-front for a dress rehearsal of No Sex and to report back. Sitting in the stalls with the director, Tony, and about 20-minutes into the play, I whispered to him an observation, not a criticism, regarding an actor’s performance. To my horror, Tony shouted, stopped the action of the performance, and called to the actor: “Roland wants to know why you’re playing it like an old queen!” I was horrified. The actor never spoke with me again! Still, I am embarrassed, and he has been dead since 2003!

Bob Grant

Bob Grant and Kim Benwell

The show opened and was playing to capacity business. The box-office was humming. There was the “sweet-smell-of-success” at the Metro. HMM was thrilled. Then, overnight, it all went very wrong. The whole thing went pear-shaped!

On Sunday morning, 23 September, three-weeks into the run, Jonathan Daly packed his bags and departed the country—without so much as a by-your-leave. On his way to Tullamarine airport, headed for California, he called into the home of the stage manager, Lloyd Casey, and left one of two letters of explanation: “Too many injuries, doctors, pressures, anxieties, and the fear of being wiped-out financially in the courts here.” The latter being a direct reference to an impending, problematic, and HMM suspected, acrimonious divorce from his Australian wife, model, Marlene Saunders, who later married actor Terence Donovan. When HMM was told the news, all hell broke loose. He was ropeable. To keep the curtain-up, the understudy, Allan Kingsford-Smith, stepped into the breach. Bob Grant from the British television series, On The Buses, came to Australia as Jonathan’s replacement. I am not sure HMM ever forgave Jonathan Daly. Sadly, the show had lost its momentum. Despite his television fame Bob Grant did not have quite the same audience appeal. Overnight it went from a howling success to a break-even proposition. The show transferred to the Metro, Kings Cross. It played for a month and enjoyed some success. What should have been a box-office bonanza proved a moderate financial investment.

Bob Grant was married to Kim Benwell, an ex-Raymond Revue girl. Located in Soho, the Raymond Revue Bar was for many years the only London venue which offered on-stage, full-frontal nudity. She and Bob Grant were newly married. He was a gentle soul. Mrs. Grant proved more demanding! She was one of the few about whom executive producer Garry Van Egmond spoke unkindly! Bob Grant trained at the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art and had done excellent work before he landed the lead role in On The Buses. The fame was double-edged. Paradoxically, the vulgar character of Jack Harper ruined his career. He became typecast as a comedic “nudge-nudge, wink-wink” actor. He was capable of more …

*Bob Grant died 2003: suicide, carbon monoxide poisoning. He was 71.

Jonathan Daly and Malcolm Steed

Jonathan Daly said: “No Sex Please, We’re British was a very physical show. Harry M. Miller flew me to London to meet Michael Crawford who was doing the West End production. He said to me: ‘You’d better be in good shape, you’re going to get killed in this’. And I did! I got my arm broken—twice. The first time the St Kilda VFL team was in the audience. After the show they came backstage to meet me. The coach (Allan Jeans) asked: ‘What happened?’ I explained, when door came down I broke my elbow. He told to come the next morning to the Football Club and their trainers would be put at my disposal and they’d have me back on the stage that night. So, every single morning I would go to the St Kilda Football Club to meet the trainers. They got me through the play.

“When I broke my arm the second time the stagehands were on strike. The stage management were doing their jobs. They were supposed to put a mattress in place for when I dived through a window. The mattress wasn’t there. I landed on the stage and broke my arm. The next day I left Australia. Harry Miller was livid; he said he was going to kill me! I cost Anthony Marriott, who wrote and directed the play, a lot of money. Some years later I was living in London when I ran into Anthony in Piccadilly. I thought he was going to hit me! We became best friends, and together we wrote plays!”

*Anthony Marriott died April 17, 2014. Northwood, Hillingdon. He was 83.

On 21 February 1979 No Sex Please, became the longest running comedy in the history of world theatre.

Gordon Chater

Diana Perryman

You Know I Can’t Hear You When The Water’s Runningstarred Gordon Chater and Diana Perryman, together with Chris Johnston, Maggie Kirpatrick, Kerry Maguire, and Peter Reynolds; directed by Stefan Haag; designed by Robert Lloyd; and written by Robert Anderson—who wrote Tea and Sympathy, opened at the Playbox Theatre, Phillip Street, 15 March 1969, at approximately the same time I joined Harry M Miller Attractions. It was an HMM/Kenn Brodziak production. Originally the 2GB auditorium, and refurbished by HMM, The Playbox opened with An Evening with Maggie and Frank, 17 May 1968, written by South Africans, Frank Lazarus and Maggie Soboil. The production transferred to the Russell Street Theatre July 1968. The show was designed by Desmond Digby, a New Zealand-born, Australian stage designer, painter, and illustrator of children's books. Having seen them in South Australia, HMM put Maggie and Frank under a long-term contract. It was not the most successful of arrangements.

*Frank Lazarus settled in London. Maggie Soboil and her husband, jazz musician Eddie Reyes, relocated and live in LA.

*Desmond Digby—1933–2015.  

Maggie and Frank

Frank and Maggie

The thing I remember most about You Know I Can’t Hear You When The Water’s Running was the urgency of having Gordon Chater’s weekly cheque to his agent—either Vaude Vision or Telecast—in readiness for Mr. Chater’s arrival at 11am, precisely. It was delivered by courier from 647 George Street, and God forbid it should be late. Gordon stacked on a such-a-turn! “He was not going on that night!”; “Everyone was a f***** amateur”. It was, as they say in the north of England: “Better than a Saturday night turn at Empire!”  Years later, especially when I was living in London, and Gordon was doing The Elocution of Benjamin Franklin, we became great chums. Sunday lunch in his Bloomsbury flat was a regular occurrence. We remained good friends and met and talked regularly. Whenever he was in Melbourne he phoned—every morning—8 o’clock precisely, and we talked for about half-an-hour. He would say: “I’m bored, now. I’m going. Goodbye” and he would hang-up. I still have a collection of his letters he wrote me. He used a broad-nibbed, Mont Blanc fountain pen. He gave me the same pen as a gift.

You Know I Can’t Hear You, was four, one-act plays with a split set, and a lot of costume changes. Gordon wore one of the worst wigs—ever! It was a dubious piece with pretentions to 1960s anthropological relevance. Each play dealt with a specific topic: 1. male genitalia: 2. Sexual boredom, menopause, and infidelity; 3. masturbation and contraception; 4 sex and marriage recollected in senility.

Peter Reynolds

Stefan Haag

Rex Cramphorn wrote in The Bulletin magazine: “It is the worst, nastiest, play I’ve seen.” … “grindingly obscene little plays whose similar prurience is now disguised as the ‘frankness’ of the ’sixties.”

Mr. Cramphorn continued: “The cast, not surprisingly, look woeful, and Stefan Haag, the director, compromises his artistic integrity by undertaking the project without even achieving a superficial gloss. The set, to which my eye constantly wandered in an effort to avoid the actors, is an equally dispirited utility.”

Mr. Cramphorn was not yet done: “If you find a ticket in the street, don’t tear it up, send it to Mr. Willis (NSW Chief Secretary and censor). If we are going to have censorship, we might as well be spared a horror like this.”

So dubious was the content, the ticket carried a management disclaimer of responsibility-for-offence, on the basis the purchaser knew what they were paying to see. The run was short, and unsuccessful. It was not a play which, to the best of my knowledge, HMM ever applied his mind, again!

*Gordon Chater AM, 1922–1999 aged 77.

*Diana Perryman died 1979 aged 54.

*Peter Reynolds moved to Australia from the UK, 1969. His brother lived in Sydney. Tragically, Peter Reynolds, and his dog, died in a fire in his flat in Oxford Street, Paddington, Sydney, 22 April 1975. The fire was caused by a cigarette from Reynolds smoking in bed. He was 53. In the UK appeared with Viven Leigh in The Skin of our Teeth, directed by Laurence Olivier; and The Hat Trickstarring Dame Gladys Cooper.

*Stefan Haag—1925–25 December 1986. He was aged 61.

Born in Vienna, he sang with the Vienna Boys’ Choir. They were touring Australia (Perth) when war broke-out (1939) and were stranded for the duration. The boys were re-settled at St. Patrick’s Cathedral, Melbourne. Stefan decided to stay and enjoyed a successful career.

*Rex Cramphorn died Sydney, 1991, AIDS related, aged 50. 

Patrick Wymark

Sheraton Hotel, Spring Street

There were three productions of Sleuth. The first, with Patrick Wymark (Patrick Carl Cheeseman) and John Fraser, opened at the old Theatre Royal, Castlereagh Street. The reviews were brilliant, and it did excellent business. Patrick, who brought a certain gravitas to the show, came from the successful television series, The Power Game. He was a real actor—respected by all. He died in the Melbourne Sheraton Hotel, Spring Street, from a heart attack three-days before he was due to open at the Comedy Theatre. On the night of day he died, Patrick was to make an appearance on In Melbourne Tonight, hosted by Stuart Wagstaff. When he failed to arrive, they made jokes about his absence. Later in the show, Stuart announced Patrick had died. HMM and the Wymark family arranged for Patrick’s body to be repatriated. His daughter, Jane, played Joyce Barnaby—the wife of Inspector Barnaby, in Midsomer Murders.

*Patrick died October 20, 1970. He was 44.

John Fraser—photo by Angus McBean

Richard Todd

Patrick’s co-star, John Fraser, was the stage and screen actor known for, The Trials of Oscar Wilde, playing Lord Aldred Douglas, with Peter Finch as Wilde; The Dam Busters with Michael Redgrave and Richard Todd. As of the 1970s, it is now considered a breach of the Geneva Convention to attack a dam if it will release dangerous forces and consequent severe losses among the civilian population; and Tunes of Glory with Alec Guinness. John was extremely handsome—for a time he was described as “the most beautiful man in England”. He did not have a bad angle, and the camera loved him. John was a fine actor, and excellent in the part of Milo Tindle; however, the production was not without its vicissitudes. In his 2004 book, Close Up,John devotes a chapter to Sleuth. He recalls, correctly, Wymark's drinking made it difficult to rehearse: “by noon he was slurring his words and forgetting his lines”. Patrick was an alcoholic.

When Wymark mishandled the prop revolver used on stage—the barrel of which had been packed with wadding and rendered safe—John gave him an ultimatum, threatening to call-in the understudy if he thought he was drunk, again. Whether it was the ultimatum, or the shock at the thought of nearly killing his co-star (most improbable), Wymark would visit Fraser every evening, "ostensibly a social visit, but in truth to let me see that he was sober”.

Sadly, John was starting to lose his hair, and was having what was called in those days, “thatching”—a tedious hair-by-hair replacement process. Like Patrick, John brought a certain gravitas to the stage. They were an excellent coupling in the play. John was extremely charming, and it was hard to believe he had come from worst Glasgow’s slums!  Curiously, John believed his sexuality thwarted his career. Frustrated at its progress he retired and devoted his creative talents to other areas.

Sir John and James (Jimmy) Woolf founded the British production companies Romulus Films and Remus Films which were active during the 1950s and 60s. The first Romulus release was Pandora and the Flying Dutchman with James Mason and Ava Gardner, whom I visited when she lived in Ennismore Gardens and I was in Sloane Ave, Chelsea. They produced many fine films including Moulin Rouge (1952); Oliver!; The Day of the Jackal; and The Odessa File.

While the official records do not support the story, John Fraser claims the British film producer, Jimmy Woolf, had “taken a fancy”—showering him with gifts while considering which actor for title role in the epic, Lawrence of Arabia, directed by David Lean, and produced by Sam Spiegel. According to John he resisted Jimmy’s advances and the coveted role went to Peter O’Toole.

*John Fraser died, London, 2024, aged 89. He lived for many years in Tuscany with his partner of 42-years, the artist Rodney Pienaar.

*The director, Harold Lang, who was quite brilliant, and clever, died a month following Patrick, of a heart attack in a Cairo hospital, 16 November 1970. He was travelling home from Australia to the UK, via Egypt.

Stratford Johns

Gary Waldhorn

In the second production, Patrick was replaced by (Alan) Stratford Johns, whose cannon of work was substantial, including the film of Cromwell. A formidable and demanding actor, he appeared in 126-episodes of Z-Cars, and 91-episodes of Softly, Softly. He was extremely popular with audiences, and a great box-office attraction. The Comedy season proved a great success. He was married to the actress Nannette Ryder(died 2006).

*Stratford Johns, 1925–2002. He was 76.

Gary Waldhorn replaced John Fraser. Later, Gary starred as the Lord of the Manor in The Vicar Dibley. British born, Raymond Westwell directed. Curiously, Mr. Westwell was resident artistic director at The Perth Playhouse in the years I was attending productions with my boarding school. Having directed the HMM production in Melbourne, he later appeared with Gary Waldhorn in a London production at the Fortune Theatre, directed by Clifford Williams. Westwell clocked-up 2359-performances as Andrew Wyke.

Following on the success of Patrick Wymark and Stratford Johns, HMM was confident in mounting the third production starring Richard Todd and, again, Gary Waldhorn. It opened in New Zealand, 1972, at His Majesty’s Theatre, Auckland, to mostly indifferent reviews. There was a negative media campaign, orchestrated by New Zealand actors, objecting to a production which did not employ any local talent. It affected the box-office, and, I suspect, the reviews. Sleuth is a two-hander, patently its success in London had not filtered through to New Zealand. The objectors were fooled by the publicity poster which, like all good thrillers, erroneously listed a number of fictional actors—red herrings! The name Gilbert Frederick was a play on Freddie Gibson, executive producer; Irving Scott was Syd Irving, General Manager, JCW, Sydney; and Jon Fine on John Finlay, director of marketing. The ruse was necessary to protect the plot and playwright Anthony Shaffer’s inspired dénouement! In their blissful ignorance, their ridiculous militancy helped to kill-off the show. Interestingly, the failure of Sleuth was a portent. It marked the beginning of the demise of Australian productions touring New Zealand and the break-up of the J.C. Williamson theatre circuit. Four-years later, 1976, marked the ending of the world’s largest theatrical firm.

Raymond Westwell

Sleuth program

Following Auckland, Sleuth played the Opera House, Wellington, and the Palmerston North Opera House, to disappointing houses. When it opened in Melbourne at the start of an Australian tour the reviews were, again, lukewarm. The production was directed by Nick Renton—with whom I had a frosty relationship. While we have never met again, Mr. Renton has gone-on to enjoy a successful UK television career—the list of credits is mightily impressive; however, he was an inexperienced theatre director, and his production was tediously pedestrian. He was too inexperienced to service such a difficult genre—and thrillers are one of the most difficult. You have to convince the audience to suspend their disbelief. Not an easy task! He failed. In his defence, Richad Todd was not in the same calibre as Stratford Johns and Patrick Mymark.

Richard Todd and Gary Waldhorn rehearsed in London, which resulted in a temporary creative disconnect between us and them. Consequently, I, as stage director, but more importantly, John Frost, who was stage manager, did not know the show as well as was needed. In the week preceding Mr. Renton’s arrival in New Zealand, I spent days lighting the show, based on the original lighting plots from London and Australia. The set, designed by Carl Toms, was a glorious Tudor Manor house in the Wiltshire countryside. I was somewhat astonished when Mr. Renton decided he wanted to relight the show. I had learned at the lighting desk of some of the best designers, including John Sumner at the Melbourne Theatre Company, and Len Fisher, based at the Canberra Theatre. It was my opinion Mr. Renton was flexing his artistic muscle simply “because he could”. Having appraised the situation, I said: “Do what you like. I am going home!” John Frost and I left the theatre. The next morning Freddie Gibson telephoned expressing some concern at the ferocity of Mr. Renton’s complaint about me. I listened but chose to ignore. I had been spoiled for directors and I had scant regard for his limited ability. I found no reason to talk with him again and he departed on the days after the opening night, leaving me to take care of what I judged was a heavy-handed, mediocre production. Judging by the box-office, so, too, did the audience.

Richard Todd, who had been a 1940s and ’50s British heart-throb, film star—A Man Called Peter,The Dam Busters,and Reach for the Sky, was a dullish stage actor. He had serious projection problems in the large theatres. On the opening night in Auckland, HMM rushed backstage during the first act, and was stage whispering to Richard from behind the set: “Speak-up! They can’t hear you!” It did not help …

Bizarrely, Richard carried around a review of his performance in a West End production of An Ideal Husband, in which he played Lord Goring. He thought it most amusing. The review read: “Richard Todd, as Lord Goring, delivered Oscar Wilde’s epigrams like a fishwife throwing dead mackerel on a marble slab!” I knew exactly what the reviewer meant. It was exactly what he did in Sleuth!

Richard Todd was not especially tall. Having worked on several Walt Disney films, he was once referred to as “Walt Disney’s eighth-dwarf”; nor did he use a deodorant. He washed his armpits with a flannel in the interval. On unpacking Richard’s shoes, John Frost—without consulting me—thought they needed attention and took them to the local Auckland cobbler. Having never seen such shoes, he instructed the cobbler to remove the fitted lifts which added inches to Richard’s required height on stage. Handmade by Rayne Shoes, London, they costs many hundreds of pounds. Richard, naturally, was furious. John’s explanation was so amusing, all I could do was laugh. The tales of that tour are too many, and too funny, to tell!

*Richard Todd died: 2009 aged 90. For all his success, it was a life tinged with great sadness.

Garry Waldhorn was a talented and experienced stage actor, including a stint at the Royal Shakespeare Company. His Sergeant Doppler was masterful, and no-one guessed. When he made an entrance in Act 11, having discarded the padding, wig, glasses, and false nose of Doppler, and wearing only a pair of snug-fitting, burgundy, stretch jocks, there was an audible sigh from the audience. Tall and muscular, and stripped to almost naked, he was something of an Adonis.

*Gary Waldhorn: died London, 2022, aged 78. In the end, he rather locked-out the world.

RR with Maurice McCarty—Sleuth, New Zealand

The JCW mechanist on the tour of Sleuth was New Zealand born, Maurice McCarty. For a time, Maruice and I lived as distant-neighbours in Carlton. He bought a magnificent two-manual, American reed organ, even though he could not play a note. It was a glorious instrument. Many-a-time he invited me to his house to play for him, and his friends. They sat enthralled while I worked my way through the Anglican hymn book, Ancient and Modern, Revised, and Allan’s Organ Voluntaries!  

Twenty-years later, 7 April 1991, Maurice was murdered in a Sydney gay-hate crime.

On 24 November 1993, a NSW Supreme Court jury acquitted Christopher Paul McKinnon, a 22-year-old Artarmon man, of assaulting and ramming Maurice’s head against the wall of his Newtown home. McKinnon, 19, and unemployed at the time of the murder, claimed: “McCarty had made sexual advances to him and he was defending himself”. Despite hearing evidence the assailant had told friends he “rolled a fag”, the jury, which was directed in relation to both self-defence and provocation, believed McKinnon.

Those who knew Maurice did not believe the assailants claims of alcohol and the selling of cannabis. There was a suggestion a second person was involved and the murder was planned. Cunningly, McKinnon made a dock statement—an unsworn statement which cannot be subjected to cross-examination. While McKinnon had an extensive criminal history, including robbery, he had not previously committed offences of violence against homosexual men. He stole objects belonging to Maurice, including his car.

Despite emergency treatment at nearby Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, McCarty died early the next day. A postmortem examination revealed Maurice’s cause of death was blood loss and hypoxia (deprivation of oxygen), caused by significant head injuries. Maurice, who was working as head mechanist with the Australian Ballet, had been in Sydney for a month. He was 46.

*McKinnon died 2014. He was about 43.

RR with John Frost in NZ—Sleuth

The propsman on Sleuth in Auckland was a most agreeable Māori. One matinee he came in drunk, and, as a joke, he painted all the ‘soon-to-be-smashed-on-stage’ Dresden shepherdesses and Toby Jugs as Māori warriors—tongues pocking-out, and all that! I confess, I was, in those days, more earnest, and failed to see the humour. Only Maurice’s pleading allowed him to keep his job. Today, I would laugh—possibly encourage—his joking handywork.

*When it came time for me and John Frost to fly to Auckland in preparation for the New Zealand tour of Sleuth, I packed the revolver in my hand-luggage and took it with me into the cabin. It never occurred I might be breaking International Aviation Law—indeed, so egregiously, I could, if found guilty, have been sentenced to a term-of-imprisonment. I cannot recall, but I guess I brought it back to Australia in exactly the same fashion!

Patrick Macnee with Joanna Lumley and Gareth Hunt

Six Degrees of Separation!

The New Avengers, 1976–77, was a joint UK-ITV/French/Canadian production which cost £125,000–per episode to produce at Pinewood Studios. It was seen in 120 countries. Patrick revived his role as John Steed, and he was joined by Joanna Lumley (Purdy), and Gareth Hunt (Mike Gambit).

Joanna Lumley is a cousin of the one-time Australian theatre producer, Wilton Morley, whose father is the late actor, Robert Morley; his grandmother was the actress, Dame Gladys Cooper. His late brother, Sheridan Morley, was the renowned London theatre critic and best-selling author. His sister, Annabelle, is married to the Australian actor, Charles Little, one of original cast of The Boys in the Band.

It would seem Joanna Lumley spent some time in Western Australia, apparently on the coast, south of Broome, around the 80– or 90–mile beach area. I assume, through Wilton, she arrived, ultimately, in Sydney and met with HMM. While my memory lacks clarity, certainly I remember her being in his company for a short period. He told me, later in life, he was rather “taken” with her, and was delighted with her success in Absolutely Fabulous. We had a discussion about offering her a play which would be his final production. I suggested, The Kingfisher, by William Douglas Home. 

Sadly, it did not come to pass. A stylish drawing-room comedy would have been a fitting exeunt!

To be continued

Note on images

All images courtesy of the author